
Late one night in early 1971, the Earl of Old Town in Chicago stayed open an extra hour past closing so a twenty-four-year-old mailman could sing for an almost empty room.
In the chairs sat Kris Kristofferson, who had just finished his own residency set at a nearby Northside club called the Quiet Knight, alongside singer Paul Anka and Chicago folk musician Steve Goodman.
Goodman had spent months pushing Kristofferson to hear his friend John Prine. A former U.S. Army vehicle mechanic who had spent five years walking a mail route in suburban Maywood, Illinois, Prine had been writing songs in his head to pass the hours and playing local open mics at the Fifth Peg mostly to work past his own shyness.
A glowing review from film critic Roger Ebert had recently moved Prine up to regular gigs at the Earl of Old Town. Still, when he walked out in front of Kristofferson, who was already riding the success of “Me and Bobby McGee” and “Sunday Mornin’ Comin’ Down,” he played a few numbers and stepped offstage.
The small crowd urged him back. Returning with his guitar, Prine played originals including “Sam Stone,” “Hello in There,” and “Paradise,” drawing on the veterans and elderly neighbors he had encountered during his time in the service and along his postal route.
Kristofferson sat stunned, joking that the kid wrote so well they would have to break his thumbs. He later recalled that by the end of the first line, everyone in the room knew they were hearing something different, describing Prine as a twenty-four-year-old who wrote like he was two hundred and twenty.
Things moved quickly after that night. Paul Anka, who briefly stepped in as an early manager, paid for Prine and Goodman to fly to New York City, where Kristofferson was headlining a run of shows at The Bitter End in Greenwich Village.
As Prine and Goodman stepped out of a cab outside the club, they ran into Kristofferson and his band walking down the street from a bar next door between sets. On the spot, Kristofferson told the two Chicago singers he was putting them onstage that night.
Prine did not realize the room was packed with music-industry executives who had turned out to see Kristofferson. Sitting near the front was Atlantic Records executive Jerry Wexler.
Rather than keeping the showcase to himself, Kristofferson handed over the stage. Wexler approached Prine as soon as he stepped off, and the very next morning, Atlantic Records signed the Maywood mailman to a recording contract.
Wexler sent Prine to Memphis to record his 1971 self-titled debut album, with “Paradise” cut at A&R Studios in New York. Kristofferson stayed in his corner, writing the album’s liner notes and telling listeners that Prine was a voice the country needed to hear.
The respect ran both ways. Kristofferson later credited Prine’s songs with pushing him to sharpen his own writing, and the two remained close friends for nearly half a century as Prine went on to launch his own independent label, Oh Boy Records, and build a catalog covered by artists from Bonnie Raitt to Johnny Cash.
Over the decades, they kept finding their way back onto the same stages, trading songs well into their later years before Prine’s passing in 2020.
Long after both men became fixtures of American songwriting, their story still traced back to a nearly empty Chicago club after closing time, and to a star who saw a mailman step out of a New York cab and handed him the microphone.