
When Carrie Underwood began shaping her 2021 gospel album *My Savior*, the first name on her shortlist for a duet partner was CeCe Winans.
Underwood had grown up singing traditional church hymns in Checotah, Oklahoma, long before winning *American Idol* in 2005 and becoming one of country music’s biggest arena headliners. After releasing her first holiday collection, *My Gift*, in 2020, she set out to record the sacred songs she had known since childhood as a companion project.
Co-produced by Underwood and David Garcia, *My Savior* was built around acoustic arrangements, stripped-back instrumentation, and familiar hymnals rather than glossy pop-country production. That approach created room for Winans, whose career in gospel music had already earned twelve Grammy Awards before the two women ever stepped into a studio together.
Underwood personally reached out to ask if Winans would join her on “Great Is Thy Faithfulness,” a hymn written in 1923 by Thomas Chisholm with music by William Runyan. Winans accepted the invitation, bringing decades of gospel phrasing into a recording environment rooted in Nashville’s acoustic session tradition.
Rather than treating the duet as a contest between two massive voices, Underwood and Garcia kept the arrangement centered on piano, acoustic strings, and vocal blend. In interviews surrounding the March 2021 release of *My Savior*, Underwood noted that singing beside Winans had been a longtime dream and described the studio experience as an exercise in listening as much as singing.
When the album arrived on March 26, 2021, *My Savior* debuted at No. 1 on both the Billboard Top Country Albums and Top Christian Albums charts, while reaching No. 4 on the all-genre Billboard 200. Critics and church listeners alike singled out “Great Is Thy Faithfulness” as the centerpiece of the 13-track record.
To mark the album’s release, Underwood staged a global livestream concert on Easter Sunday, April 4, 2021, from Nashville’s Ryman Auditorium. Built in 1892 as the Union Gospel Tabernacle before becoming the longtime home of the Grand Ole Opry, the Ryman carried deep historical ties to both country music and sacred hymns.
During the broadcast, Winans joined Underwood onstage beneath the venue’s stained-glass windows and curved wooden pews. With no live audience filling the hall because of pandemic restrictions, the performance unfolded in an unusually quiet room, drawing focus to every breath and harmony between the two singers.
Throughout the hymn, neither vocalist pushed to overpower the other. Underwood stood watching Winans with visible admiration during her solo verses, and when their voices came together on the chorus, the two clasped hands at center stage.
The Easter Sunday livestream raised more than $112,000 for Save the Children, extending the reach of the album well beyond chart numbers. The following year, *My Savior* won the Grammy Award for Best Roots Gospel Album at the 64th Annual Grammy Awards, while “Great Is Thy Faithfulness” took home Inspirational Recorded Song of the Year at the 2021 GMA Dove Awards.
For Winans, who was still living, recording, and touring as one of gospel’s defining voices, the duet added another milestone to a four-decade catalog. For Underwood, it fulfilled a goal she had carried since her church choir days in Oklahoma.
Long after the awards were handed out and the livestream ended, the partnership remained defined by how it was made: an acoustic hymn recorded out of mutual respect, carried onto the Ryman stage with two singers holding hands in an empty hall.