
When Dolly Parton walked into RCA Studio B in Nashville on June 12, 1973, to record “I Will Always Love You,” the session was the direct result of a bargain struck across Porter Wagoner’s desk. After seven years as the co-star of *The Porter Wagoner Show*, Parton had struggled to convince the man known across Nashville as Mr. Grand Ole Opry to let her leave for a solo career.
Arguments had gone nowhere until the morning Parton carried an acoustic guitar into Wagoner’s private office and sang the farewell ballad she had written the night before. Listening to her voice, the famously strict bandleader began to cry. He told her it was the best song she had ever written and agreed to release her from the program on one condition: he wanted to produce the record.
At RCA Studio B, the track came together with a lineup of seasoned Nashville session musicians, including Hargus “Pig” Robbins on piano, Stu Basore on steel guitar, Larrie Londin on drums, and Buck Trent on banjo. Although RCA staff producer Bob Ferguson held the official label credit on the *Jolene* album sessions, Wagoner stayed closely involved in guiding the project and kept his word, continuing to produce Parton’s solo albums through 1976’s *All I Can Do*.
RCA Victor released “I Will Always Love You” as a single on March 11, 1974, making it the second single from *Jolene*. On the B-side sat “Lonely Comin’ Down,” a song written by Wagoner himself—a quiet reminder of the partnership even as it came to a close.
The record moved quickly up the charts. Debuting at No. 87 on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart on April 6, 1974, it climbed to No. 1 ten weeks later on June 8, becoming Parton’s third chart-topping single. That same month, Parton and Wagoner performed their final show together.
Success on the country charts soon brought a second test, this time over who would own the song’s future. Not long after the single hit No. 1, Elvis Presley expressed interest in recording his own version. Parton was thrilled at the prospect; an Elvis cut guaranteed worldwide exposure and immediate commercial weight.
The night before the scheduled session, however, Presley’s manager, Colonel Tom Parker, called Parton with a firm condition. Parker told her it was standard procedure for any songwriter to sign over half of the publishing rights to a song Presley recorded.
In the music business, surrendering half the publishing meant permanently giving up fifty percent of the song’s ownership and future royalties. Many struggling writers accepted Parker’s terms in exchange for the career boost of an Elvis recording. Parton did not.
She told Parker she could not sign over half of her most important song, noting that she had already written, published, and scored a hit with it, and that her publishing catalog was what she intended to leave for her family. The recording session was called off. Parton later recalled telling Parker she was sorry and then crying all night over the missed chance to hear Presley sing her words.
Keeping full ownership of the copyright proved to be one of the most consequential business decisions of her career. When Whitney Houston recorded “I Will Always Love You” for the 1992 film *The Bodyguard*, the ballad became a global phenomenon. Because Parton had retained 100 percent of her publishing rights, she collected the full songwriter royalties—an estimated $10 million from Houston’s version during the 1990s alone, alongside millions more in the decades that followed.
Those earnings helped fund her business ventures and philanthropic work back in East Tennessee, turning a personal goodbye into a lasting financial foundation.
In later years, Parton spoke of Wagoner’s tears in that Nashville office as one of the most sacred moments of her life. In an industry built on hard bargains, one man had chosen to let go and help launch the song that took her away, and the woman who wrote it refused to hand over half of what it was worth.