
When Dolly Parton called Reba McEntire after the March 1991 plane crash that took eight members of Reba’s road organization, she offered to hand over her own touring band on the spot.
Three minutes had separated the two chartered jets that lifted off from San Diego’s Brown Field Municipal Airport in the early dark of March 16, 1991. Recovering from bronchitis after a private show for IBM executives, Reba had stayed behind at a local hotel with her husband and manager, Narvel Blackstock, and her stylist, Sandi Spika, after a doctor advised her against flying overnight in an unpressurized cabin.
At 1:45 a.m., the first aircraft clipped a rock on the side of Otay Mountain ten miles east of the runway. All ten people aboard lost their lives, including bandmates Chris Austin, Kirk Cappello, Joey Cigainero, Paula Kaye Evans, Terry Jackson, Anthony Saputo, and Michael Thomas, along with tour manager Jim Hammon and pilots Donald Holmes and Christopher Hollinger.
The second chartered plane, carrying steel guitarist Pete Finney alongside another band member and the rest of the road crew, had taken off right behind them. Its pilot saw nothing in the fog, knew only that radio contact had vanished, and was later diverted to Nashville instead of continuing toward their scheduled concert in Fort Wayne, Indiana.
Back in San Diego, after the pilot of the second jet phoned the hotel past 2:00 a.m., Blackstock went with family friend Roger Woolsey to confirm the identities of their friends so Reba would be spared the scene. Returning to their room before dawn, he knelt beside the bed, took her hands, and told her no one on the first plane had survived, before walking from room to room with a telephone to notify the families.
Once Reba, Blackstock, and the surviving crew returned to Tennessee, the entire Nashville community stepped in around them. Johnny Cash spoke at the memorial service held for the victims’ families, while Blackstock and Reba covered the funeral expenses and provided financial support for the households left behind.
For weeks, Reba questioned whether she could ever walk back onto a concert stage without the people who had shared her life on the road. Only nine days after the accident, at the urging of Vince Gill and the families of the musicians she had lost, she wore a simple black velvet dress to the 63rd Academy Awards on March 25 to perform her nominated song from the film Postcards from the Edge.
Actually rebuilding a permanent touring family for the road proved much harder than a single television appearance. Both Gill and Parton offered their full bands so Reba could fulfill her upcoming concert dates, and Gill told her directly that he would show up and play guitar for her himself whenever she needed him.
Rather than borrowing another artist’s group, Reba and Blackstock chose to build a new lineup around the surviving members from the second plane. Parton sent her own bandleader, Gary Smith, to help organize and audition the new musicians, easing the burden on a Starstruck Entertainment staff still grieving their coworkers.
Among the voices who joined the rebuilt road family was backing vocalist Linda Davis, who sang harmonies on the autumn 1991 album For My Broken Heart and later recorded a chart-topping duet with Reba. Dedicated to the eight colleagues lost on Otay Mountain, that October release reached number one and sold more than four million copies.
Even with a new band standing behind her, the muscle memory of the old lineup took months to fade. In the middle of live sets, Reba still caught herself turning to her right to share a look with Paula Kaye Evans before remembering the stage beside her had changed.
She also quietly retired her concert cover of Patsy Cline’s signature ballad. During the San Diego show on the night before the crash, Jim Hammon had confiscated an unauthorized audience tape and handed it to Blackstock before heading to the airport, leaving behind a final recording of the band that included Reba singing the tune a cappella.
More than three decades later, and eleven years after she and Blackstock ended their twenty-six-year marriage in 2015, the bond forged among the survivors of that spring has never loosened. Every March 16, the woman who wondered if she could ever sing again still pauses to call out the names of the friends who never made it home from California.