
When Mercury Records Nashville president Luke Lewis passed on Toby Keith’s new recordings in 1998, the singer picked up a check from his accountant, bought back his own master tapes, and carried them out of the building under his arm.
That confrontation had been building since Harold Shedd, the Mercury executive who originally flew to Oklahoma and signed Keith before his 1993 debut Should’ve Been a Cowboy, left the company. As corporate leadership shifted across Mercury, Polydor, and A&M during the mid-1990s, the new front office began steering Keith toward polished ballads and softer radio fare.
Keith had learned a very different lesson during the 1980s while working Oklahoma oil rigs by day and playing dance halls at night. Watching Hank Williams Jr. pack arenas behind dark sunglasses and a full beard without letting Music Row smooth out his rough edges convinced Keith that an outspoken six-foot-four songwriter from Oklahoma did not need to fit an industry mold either.
The breaking point arrived when Keith turned in a finished album anchored by a brash, horn-driven track he had written with Chuck Cannon called How Do You Like Me Now?!. Lewis hated the project and warned that female country listeners would never accept the title song.
Sitting in Lewis’s office, Keith asked the label to release him from his contract. When Lewis asked if he truly believed in the rejected music that much, Keith said yes.
Two hours later, Lewis called to say Keith could purchase the recordings outright. Depending on the accounting fees cited in later interviews, Keith paid roughly $93,000 to $110,000 for the masters, walked out a free agent, and took the tapes to producer James Stroud at DreamWorks Records Nashville.
DreamWorks paid Keith $200,000 for the album, added two more tracks, and released How Do You Like Me Now?! in November 1999. The very song Mercury had refused to issue spent five weeks at No. 1 on the Radio & Records chart, became the most-played country song of 2000, and pushed the album past three million copies sold.
At the Academy of Country Music Awards following that run, Keith took home both Album of the Year and Male Vocalist of the Year for the recordings he had carried out of Mercury’s offices. That DreamWorks partnership launched the biggest commercial stretch of his career, producing multi-platinum albums including Pull My Chain in 2001, Unleashed in 2002, and Shock’n Y’all in 2003.
Even as he became one of the highest-earning touring acts in the country, Keith kept his distance from Music Row politics. Like Hank Williams Jr., with whom he later shared stages and duets, he publicly criticized award show voting and skipped ceremonies when he felt overlooked.
By 2004, corporate consolidation caught up with him again when Universal Music Group acquired DreamWorks and folded its Nashville roster back under Luke Lewis’s oversight. Unwilling to answer to the same executive structure a second time, Keith fulfilled his final DreamWorks commitment with 2005’s Honkytonk University and prepared to leave the major-label system altogether.
On August 31, 2005, he founded his own independent label, Show Dog Nashville. Beginning with his 2006 platinum album White Trash with Money, Keith produced his own records and controlled every step from songwriting to distribution.
Four years later, in December 2009, he merged the company with Universal South to form Show Dog-Universal Music, signing fellow artists including Trace Adkins, Clay Walker, and his daughter Krystal Keith.
Before his death in February 2024 at age 62, Keith was elected to the Country Music Hall of Fame after building a business empire that traced directly back to 1998, the afternoon he handed over a check and carried his own master tapes out the door.