
When Jimmy Fortune walked into Young ‘Un Sound studio in Nashville with The Statler Brothers in 1983, the 27-year-old tenor was still working under a temporary agreement that offered no guarantee he would last the year.
For nearly four decades before Fortune’s arrival, the vocal identity of the Virginia quartet belonged to Harold Reid, Don Reid, Phil Balsley, and original tenor Lew DeWitt. DeWitt had written the group’s signature 1965 crossover hit “Flowers on the Wall” and helped establish their harmony sound during eight years touring as part of Johnny Cash’s road show. When severe Crohn’s disease forced DeWitt to take a hiatus in late 1981, fans across the country viewed the lineup as untouchable.
DeWitt himself found his successor close to home in Virginia. While recovering, he remembered hearing a young Nelson County musician named Jimmy Fortune singing nightly for skiers at the Wintergreen Resort. After an audition in January 1982 in Salem, Virginia, Fortune joined the group on the road, initially filling in while everyone hoped DeWitt might recover enough to return.
By the summer of 1982, DeWitt made his departure permanent, and the pressure on Fortune intensified. Night after night, he stepped up to the microphone before audiences who had spent decades listening to DeWitt’s clear tenor. Between shows, Fortune retreated to a back corner of the group’s custom tour bus with his acoustic guitar, trying to find a way to earn his keep beyond singing parts another man had made famous.
That breakthrough began in a hotel room after Fortune watched the classic film “Gone with the Wind” on television. The story stayed with him as the bus rolled toward the next town, and he started working out a melody and chords in his usual corner seat. Because the name Scarlett did not fit the rhythm of the chorus he was building, he substituted the three-syllable name “Elizabeth” and finished a rough version of the ballad on the road.
Bringing an outside song to The Statler Brothers was no small step. Across dozens of albums for Columbia and Mercury Records, Don and Harold Reid, along with DeWitt, had written nearly every original track the quartet recorded. When Fortune nervously played “Elizabeth” for Harold Reid, Don Reid, and Phil Balsley, the three veteran members immediately recognized what their young tenor had written.
They brought the song to longtime producer Jerry Kennedy during the Nashville sessions for their 1983 Mercury album, “Today.” Rather than blending Fortune into a shared lead or keeping him strictly in the background harmonies, the Reid brothers and Balsley stepped back to form a three-part vocal cushion behind him. Kennedy framed the arrangement around Fortune’s high, clear lead vocal, allowing the newest member to carry the entire song in the studio.
Mercury released “Elizabeth” as a single in October 1983. Over the next four months, the ballad climbed steadily up the radio surveys until it reached number one on the Billboard Hot Country Singles chart in March 1984. It became The Statler Brothers’ first chart-topping record since “Do You Know You Are My Sunshine” in 1978, ending a six-year drought at the top of the charts.
Back in Virginia, DeWitt followed the song’s rise and publicly supported the young tenor he had discovered at Wintergreen. Though complications from his illness later claimed DeWitt’s life in August 1990 at age 52, the chart success of “Elizabeth” assured him during his lifetime that the quartet he helped build remained strong.
For Fortune, the record changed every night on tour. When the opening notes of “Elizabeth” rang out in auditoriums and fairgrounds, longtime fans who had once looked at him with hesitation rose to their feet in applause. The song’s success also established him as a core songwriter inside the group alongside the Reid brothers.
Over the next two years, Fortune repeated that feat twice more. He wrote and sang lead on “My Only Love,” which reached number one in early 1985 on the album “Atlanta Blue,” followed by “Too Much on My Heart,” which topped the country chart later that year and stayed on the survey for 24 weeks. Those three self-penned hits anchored The Statler Brothers’ mid-1980s resurgence and helped pave the way for their popular weekly variety series on The Nashville Network in the 1990s.
In 2002, after two decades of sharing harmonies across North America, Harold Reid, Don Reid, Phil Balsley, and Jimmy Fortune played their farewell concert in Salem, Virginia, the same city where Fortune had auditioned 20 years earlier. Six years later, the man who once sat in the corner of the tour bus wondering if he belonged stood beside his bandmates as The Statler Brothers were inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame.