
On July 24, 1970, eleven-year-old Marty Stuart asked his mother to buy him a brand-new yellow shirt so Connie Smith might spot him in the crowd at the Choctaw Indian Fair in Philadelphia, Mississippi.
After the show, the young mandolin player walked up to the car where the twenty-eight-year-old star of “Once a Day” was seated behind the stage, got her autograph, and snapped the first photograph he ever took with a camera. On the drive home that evening, he told his mother that he was going to marry Connie Smith when he grew up.
Over the next two decades, their lives moved in separate directions across Nashville. While Stuart joined Lester Flatt’s band at age thirteen, spent six years touring in Johnny Cash’s road group, and went through an early marriage to Cash’s daughter Cindy, Smith stepped back from the relentless touring schedule of the late 1960s and 1970s to raise her five children and focus on her Christian faith and Grand Ole Opry appearances.
After going through three divorces, Smith decided she would remain single for the rest of her life. By the mid-1990s, she had not released a new studio album in nearly twenty years when Warner Bros. Records executive Jim Ed Norman approached her about returning to the recording studio and brought Stuart in to produce the project.
Before stepping into the control room, Stuart suggested that the two of them sit down with acoustic guitars and try writing original material together for the record. When Smith arrived for their first scheduled songwriting appointment and asked what kind of song they were going to write, Stuart answered that he wanted to write a love song.
Across those mid-1990s writing sessions, the pair co-wrote eight of the ten tracks that eventually appeared on her 1998 self-titled comeback album, including “Hearts Like Ours,” “You Can’t Stop Love,” and “Looking for a Reason.” In the studio, Stuart surrounded her soprano voice with steel guitarist Ralph Mooney and twin fiddles rather than contemporary pop production, and their working sessions gradually grew into a courtship despite their seventeen-year age difference.
During the months they spent writing and recording together, Stuart also brought Smith along to one of the places outside the music business that mattered most to him: the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in southwestern South Dakota. Stuart had first visited Pine Ridge in the early 1980s when Johnny Cash’s tour bus pulled into the Oglala Lakota community to play a benefit concert and show support for the residents.
Drawn back to the reservation year after year, Stuart spent decades photographing everyday life and ceremonies on the plains, joining traditional sweat lodge rituals, and assisting with local community initiatives. The Oglala Lakota people eventually adopted Stuart into the tribe as a family member, giving him the Lakota name *Oyate Olowan Wicasa* and honoring his ongoing work with the community.
When Stuart and Smith decided to wed in the summer of 1997, they bypassed a large Nashville industry ceremony and traveled north to Pine Ridge so they could exchange vows among the Lakota friends who had welcomed them during their courtship. On July 8, 1997, twenty-seven years after their first meeting at the Mississippi fairgrounds, they were married in a private traditional Lakota ceremony on the South Dakota prairie.
Along with the spiritual setting of the reservation, Stuart later admitted to reporters that marrying in South Dakota solved a practical problem that had worried him before the trip. At the time, several states still required couples to submit to a clinical blood test before the county clerk would issue a marriage license, and South Dakota had no such requirement.
Stuart explained with a laugh that he suffered from a lifelong fear of needles and blood, noting that he routinely passed out cold whenever a nurse tried to draw a sample at a doctor’s office. Because South Dakota law skipped the needle altogether, the groom was able to get the marriage license and stay upright on his feet through the entire Lakota wedding ceremony.
After the vows concluded on the reservation, the newlyweds drove out into the South Dakota Badlands, turned up Buck Owens’s recording of “Your Tender Loving Care” on the car stereo, and danced together on a cliff above the plains. Twenty-seven years after a boy in a yellow shirt stood beside a car at the Choctaw Indian Fair in Mississippi, Marty Stuart and Connie Smith drove back toward Tennessee as husband and wife without a single bandage on the groom’s arm.