
By the summer of 2004, twenty-one-year-old Carrie Underwood was a college senior in Tahlequah, Oklahoma, just a few credits short of a broadcast journalism degree and preparing for a career behind a local news desk.
Three years earlier, she had deliberately closed the door on music. Growing up on her parents’ cattle farm outside Checotah, the youngest of three daughters had chased singing throughout her childhood, singing at First Free Will Baptist Church, county fairs, and local festivals. When she was fourteen, a local admirer arranged an audition in Nashville and neighbors pooled money to help fund the trip, nearly landing her a recording contract with Capitol Records before a corporate leadership shakeup killed the deal.
When she graduated from Checotah High School as salutatorian in May 2001, the eighteen-year-old looked closely at her family’s finances. Her two older sisters, Shanna and Stephanie, were already grown and married, leaving her father, Stephen, working shifts at a paper mill and her mother, Carole, teaching elementary school.
Unwilling to burden her aging parents with the cost of an uncertain move to Nashville, Underwood packed away her demo tapes that summer and enrolled about forty-five miles northeast at Northeastern State University.
From the fall of 2001 through 2004, she built a practical life in Tahlequah as a mass communication major. To pay her own rent and bills without calling home for help, she waited tables at a local pizzeria, cleaned kennels at a veterinary clinic, and worked at a nearby zoo.
She joined the Alpha Iota chapter of the Sigma Sigma Sigma sorority, played intramural softball, and competed in campus pageants, finishing as first runner-up for Miss NSU in 2004. Music was no longer her career plan, though she kept her voice in shape during two summers performing in the university’s Downtown Country stage revue in Tahlequah and serving as a page and intern for Oklahoma State Representative Bobby Frame.
That self-imposed practicality held firm until mid-2004, when she watched a television segment anunciar open auditions for the fourth season of *American Idol*. Because the closest cattle call was in St. Louis, Missouri, she hesitated until her mother offered to make the seven-hour drive with her.
In August 2004, Carole drove Carrie to St. Louis for the early stadium rounds at the Edward Jones Dome, followed by the televised judges’ audition at the Hyatt Regency hotel. Dressed in basic jeans and a pink top, the college senior stood before judges Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, and Randy Jackson, admitting she had never flown on an airplane before.
Instead of a flashy showcase number, she sang an understated version of Bonnie Raitt’s ballad “I Can’t Make You Love Me”. During the audition, she even obliged Randy Jackson’s lighthearted request to demonstrate that she could cluck like a chicken before earning her golden ticket to Hollywood, boarding her first commercial flight to California that fall.
Across the spring of 2005, she never trailed in the weekly viewer voting, culminating in her May 25, 2005 finale victory and the release of her seven-times-platinum debut album, *Some Hearts*, later that November.
Even with a recording contract, tour buses, and her first Grammy Awards on the horizon, Underwood refused to leave her Oklahoma college promise unfinished. Because her final semester had been interrupted by the competition in Los Angeles, she worked with her professors to complete her remaining coursework and internship credits after becoming a household name.
On May 6, 2006, nearly a year after winning the title, she returned to Tahlequah in a black cap and gown to walk across the stage at Northeastern State University, graduating magna cum laude with her bachelor’s degree in mass communication while Stephen and Carole watched from the stands.