
On May 26, 2015, a trade interview in *Country Aircheck Weekly* triggered one of the loudest public clashes in modern country music.
In the piece, radio consultant Keith Hill advised station programmers to cut female artists from their playlists if they wanted higher ratings. He recommended keeping women to roughly 15 percent of airplay, warned against playing two female singers back to back, and compared male stars like Luke Bryan, Blake Shelton, and Keith Urban to the lettuce in a salad while calling women the tomatoes.
Within hours, the remarks jumped from an industry newsletter to the public square under the hashtag SaladGate. Martina McBride was among the first to respond, posting an excerpt of Hill’s interview to her 1.8 million Facebook followers and asking listeners whether that was truly how they felt. She later warned that such philosophies risked becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy for labels investing in female acts, songwriters pitching material, and stations deciding who got a fair shot.
Miranda Lambert answered with even less restraint. On Twitter, she dismissed Hill’s advice as the biggest bunch of “BULLSHIT” she had ever heard and made a public promise: she would do everything in her power to support and promote female singer-songwriters in country music.
Other artists quickly followed. Jennifer Nettles, Kacey Musgraves, Brandy Clark, Kelsea Ballerini, and Maddie & Tae all pushed back online, joined by veteran radio programmer Leslie Fram, who called the claims an insult to every woman in the format.
Hill did not walk the analogy back. In a June 1, 2015 follow-up with *Country Aircheck*, he stated that he would not apologize for the tomato comparison, though he acknowledged that fans who loved artists like Carrie Underwood and Lambert were angry because they viewed the industry as sexist. He later told CBS News that his comments had been meant for industry insiders rather than a mass audience.
Despite the uproar, country radio moved slowly. Six months after the controversy, *Country Aircheck*’s 2015 Country Top 100 listed only 20 entries by female solo artists, duos, or groups, with Kelsea Ballerini’s “Love Me Like You Mean It” charting highest at No. 13. Subsequent studies found that the airplay gap persisted in the years that followed.
Lambert did not wait for program directors to change their logs. Having launched her Certified Platinum Tour in January 2015, she used her fall 2015 Roadside Bars and Pink Guitars Tour to put her tweet into practice. She built the bill around emerging female acts, bringing RaeLynn, Clare Dunn, Courtney Cole, and Ashley Monroe onto the road—and even hosting an unplugged Nashville club show with them that July.
Concertgoers answered directly. Fans began showing up at venues in shirts printed with tomatoes, turning an industry consultant’s dismissal into a visible statement across arena floors.
Lambert kept that touring blueprint intact through the 2016 Keeper of the Flame Tour, keeping her focus on live crowds rather than chasing radio formulas. Then, in September 2019, she reprised Roadside Bars and Pink Guitars on an even larger scale.
That 2019 run packed arenas with an all-female lineup featuring Maren Morris, Elle King, Tenille Townes, and Lambert’s own trio, Pistol Annies, alongside Ashley Monroe and Angaleena Presley. Night after night, newer voices stepped directly in front of tens of thousands of ticket-buying fans without waiting for a single spin on the dial.
By the end of the decade, radio executives still held the playlists, and the airplay numbers remained lopsided. Out on the road, however, Lambert and the women who opened her shows had built a parallel circuit where the audience decided who belonged at the center of the stage.
Four years after a trade magazine called them the garnish, an all-female bill was still walking out under arena lights in cities like Charlottesville, guitars in hand, in front of crowds that had paid to see every single one of them.