
When Connie Smith signed with Warner Bros. Records in 1996 for her first studio album of new material in nearly twenty years, Marty Stuart stepped into the studio to co-write nine of the ten tracks and produce the sessions.
That collaboration began in 1994 after the two reconnected backstage at the Grand Ole Opry and before a celebrity softball game in Nashville, when Smith asked Stuart to write for her comeback project. Unbeknownst to Smith, the musician seventeen years her junior had kept a 1970 Polaroid photograph taken with her in Philadelphia, Mississippi, when he was twelve years old.
Back in 1970, wearing a brand-new yellow shirt his mother Hilda had bought him so the “Once a Day” singer might notice him in the Mississippi crowd, young Stuart had posed with Smith for a snapshot and announced on the ride home that he was going to marry the woman in the picture. Over the next two decades, he kept that photograph through his teenage years playing mandolin in Lester Flatt’s band, his six years touring with Johnny Cash, and his first marriage to Cindy Cash.
By the time Stuart arrived at Smith’s house to write in 1994, the fifty-three-year-old Grand Ole Opry member had vowed never to marry again. Raised in Ohio with a violent father before surviving a 1968 mental exhaustion breakdown at the peak of her RCA Victor fame, she had walked away from full-time touring to focus on her Christian faith and her four children.
She had also lived through three divorces: first from steelworker Jerry Smith, the father of her son Darren; next from her road guitarist Jack Watkins; and finally in the early 1990s from former televangelist Marshall Haynes, the father of her daughters Kerry, Julie, and Jeanne. Convinced she was unsuited for marriage, she planned to spend the rest of her life single.
During their first afternoon writing together, Stuart telephoned Hall of Fame songwriter Harlan Howard so Smith could work alongside one of her favorite composers. Over the next three years, Stuart and Smith wrote songs at her kitchen table, including “Hearts Like Ours,” “You Can’t Take Back a Broken Heart,” and “Looking for a Reason.”
When Stuart began asking her out, Smith warned him that she was too old, had four grown and teenage children, and had closed the door on romance. Rather than pressing her, Stuart spent more than three years showing up steadily in her routine, drinking coffee with her, praying with her, winning the trust of Darren, Kerry, Julie, and Jeanne, and setting aside his own hard-living road habits.
In the studio control room with co-producer Justin Niebank, Stuart built the arrangements around her phrasing and turned down label suggestions for a commercial duets record so the October 1998 album *Connie Smith* would showcase her voice alone. Three months before that album reached stores, she agreed to become his wife.
On July 8, 1997, thirty-eight-year-old Stuart and fifty-five-year-old Smith traveled to the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota, where Stuart had long been an adopted member of the Oglala Lakota community. Surrounded by their families and Lakota friends, they were married in a four-hour traditional Lakota Sioux ceremony presided over by a tribal holy man.
After the vows, the newlyweds drove out into the South Dakota badlands, parked near the edge of a cliff, and danced together to a cassette of Buck Owens singing “Your Tender Loving Care”. Back in Nashville, when Grand Ole Opry peer Bill Anderson joked with Smith about why she had never changed her last name to something more exotic, she replied that she already had—two or three times.
In the decades that followed, Stuart continued to frame his wife’s career as a national treasure, featuring her weekly alongside his band, the Fabulous Superlatives, across all six seasons of *The Marty Stuart Show* on RFD-TV from 2008 to 2014. Together they co-wrote five more songs for her 2011 Sugar Hill album *Long Line of Heartaches*—which included her daughters Julie and Jeanne singing backup on the closing track—beforeStuart produced her 2021 LP *The Cry of the Heart* and 2024’s *Love, Prison, Wisdom and Heartaches*.
Nearly three decades after their wedding on the South Dakota plains, the 1970 Mississippi fairground Polaroid of the twelve-year-old boy in the yellow shirt still remained in the home he shared with the woman standing beside him in the frame.