
In 1957, music executives told 24-year-old Harold Lloyd Jenkins his birth name was too plain to sell records, asking him to give up the one thing his family had given him.
He had already spent months driving into Memphis to record rockabilly tracks at Sam Phillips’s Sun Studio. None of the sides he cut under his birth name were released at the time, though Phillips handed one of his original compositions, “Rockhouse,” to labelmate Roy Orbison. Managers and label bosses insisted that Harold Jenkins would never catch the eye of young pop fans on concert posters.
For a young man raised between Friars Point, Mississippi, and Helena, Arkansas, the request felt like turning his back on home. He had learned his first guitar chords at age ten sitting on the deck of a Mississippi River ferryboat captained by his father, Floyd Jenkins, and hosted his own Saturday morning radio show in Helena by twelve. He wanted his father and his mother, Velma, to look at a record label and know immediately that their boy had made it.
Velma felt the sting of the change at first, yet she urged her son to do whatever his career required. Realizing a major label contract depended on it, he sat down with his manager and spread out a United States road map in 1957. He pointed to Conway, Arkansas, keeping a piece of the state his family had called home since he was ten, and paired it with Twitty, Texas.
Even the new name brought no instant luck. Mercury Records signed Conway Twitty in 1957, released two singles that stalled out at number 93 on the pop chart, and dropped him before the year ended.
By 1958, he was signed to MGM and working club dates across Ontario, Canada, to keep his band afloat. One night between sets at the Flamingo Lounge in Hamilton, he and his drummer, Jack Nance, put together a slow, aching ballad called “It’s Only Make Believe”. MGM treated the track as an afterthought and promoted the flip side, “I’ll Try,” until a radio disc jockey in Columbus, Ohio, flipped the record over.
The song climbed to number one in the United States and 21 other countries, selling millions of copies and turning him into a rock-and-roll teen idol with subsequent hits like “Lonely Blue Boy”. Yet the screaming crowds never sat right with a singer who kept a growing stack of unrecorded country songs in his suitcase.
For a while, he seriously considered splitting his identity in two, keeping Conway Twitty for pop records while reclaiming Harold Jenkins for the country songs he actually wanted to sing. In 1965, halfway through a rock-and-roll set at a nightclub in New Jersey, he stopped playing, set down his guitar, and walked off the stage for good.
He bought out his management contract, moved to Oklahoma City to play country clubs, and signed with producer Owen Bradley at Decca Records in Nashville. Because his pop fame already carried weight, he kept the stage name, even though skeptical country disc jockeys refused to play his early releases for nearly three years. His persistence broke through in late 1968 when “Next in Line” reached number one, followed in 1970 by “Hello Darlin'”.
Across a career that ultimately produced 55 number-one singles across trade charts, every check, tax return, and property deed still bore the signature of Harold L. Jenkins. When his restaurant venture, Twitty Burger, collapsed in the early 1970s, it was under the legal name Harold L. Jenkins that he fought in U.S. Tax Court after personally repaying the country fans and friends who had invested in him.
In 1982, he used the fortune Conway Twitty earned to open Twitty City, a nine-acre complex in Hendersonville, Tennessee. Alongside the gardens and exhibition halls built to welcome his fans, he built homes on the property for his mother Velma and his four children, Michael, Joni, Kathy, and Jimmy. Inside those gates, nobody called him Conway.
When he died in June 1993 at age 59 after collapsing on his tour bus in Branson, Missouri, his final resting place in Sumner County settled the divide permanently. The gravestone places Harold Lloyd Jenkins at the top, tucking Conway Twitty quietly in quotation marks beneath the name his parents gave him.