
When Carrie Underwood and Mike Fisher sat down together in front of the cameras in May 2020, they were approaching their tenth wedding anniversary and ready to talk plainly about how rocky the beginning had been.
The couple had met in 2008 after one of Underwood’s concerts and married in 2010. At the time, Fisher was more than a decade into his NHL career with the Ottawa Senators, and it was not until his 2011 trade to the Nashville Predators that the two finally settled under the same roof in Tennessee.
In *Mike and Carrie: God & Country*, a four-part digital short-film series released weekly on iamsecond.com starting May 27, 2020, the pair pulled back the curtain on those early years. Fisher had previously shared his own testimony with the organization *I Am Second* in 2014, recalling how reaching the NHL at age 19 left him unexpectedly empty. Six years later, he and Underwood returned together to show how their shared faith held up inside an actual marriage.
Episode 1, titled “I Cry Easy,” went straight to the fault line that tested them between 2010 and 2012. Underwood had stopped eating red meat at age 13 on her family’s farm in Checotah, Oklahoma, after hearing mother cows call out when separated from their calves. Fisher, raised in Peterborough, Ontario, came from a family where hunting wildlife was a lifelong tradition.
On camera, Fisher laughed at how poorly each of them had predicted the other’s reaction. “When we got married, you thought I was going to stop hunting and I thought you weren’t going to care, and all of a sudden, it’s like, ‘Whoa,'” he recalled.
Underwood’s independent streak and years of living on her own terms made the adjustment harder. Rather than pretending the disagreements vanished, she described their dynamic plainly in the series. “We learn from each other, and we have spirited discussions on things we disagree on,” Underwood said. “But at the end of the day, we love each other very much”.
When those discussions reached a stalemate, the couple turned to a habit that pulled them out of trying to win an argument: they knelt down and prayed together. Fisher explained in the series that their faith gave them a center ground where their differences stopped being the deciding factor.
That understanding also required clear boundaries in daily life. To honor his wife’s convictions and keep peace at home, Fisher voluntarily promised never to bring beef or wild game into the house to cook, a rule he kept year after year.
Across the rest of the four-part series, the couple showed how the habits they built in those first two years carried them through heavier seasons. In Episode 1, Underwood admitted she had been hesitant about having children until their first son, Isaiah, was born in 2015. Episode 2, “The Wrestle,” addressed the three miscarriages they suffered afterward, with Underwood recounting how she told God directly how hurt she was.
Episode 3, “Just Blurt Out Whatever,” followed their home life with Isaiah and their second son, Jacob, who arrived in January 2019, focusing on the everyday conversations they had about faith at the kitchen table.
By the final episode, “If I Were Married to Myself,” the tone shifted back to the differences that had once caused friction. After retiring from the NHL in 2018 following 18 seasons, Fisher launched an outdoor and hunting apparel company called *Catchin’ Deers*. Sitting beside him on camera, Underwood joked about his singing voice while he teased her about hockey, two people completely comfortable with the fact that they had never turned into the same person.
Ten years after their wedding, the hunter and the vegetarian were still sharing the same house in Tennessee, with Fisher’s outdoor gear in one corner and a meat-free kitchen in the other.