
When Connie Smith began searching in 1994 for the songs that would become her first new studio album in nearly twenty years, she had already rejected several preliminary Warner Bros. recording sessions before asking thirty-six-year-old Marty Stuart to sit across from her with an acoustic guitar.
Twenty-four years earlier, in the summer of 1970, a twelve-year-old Stuart had stood near the stage at the Choctaw Indian Fair in Philadelphia, Mississippi, to watch the twenty-nine-year-old Grand Ole Opry star perform. After getting his picture taken with her by her tour bus, he climbed into the family car and told his mother, Hilda, that he was going to marry Connie Smith one day.
By the mid-1990s, their lives looked nothing alike on paper. Smith was in her fifties, a devout Christian who had stepped away from full-time recording at the height of her fame to raise five children through three ended marriages, while Stuart wore black leather, played driving country-rock, and was years removed from an early marriage to Johnny Cash’s daughter, Cindy.
Their reunion began strictly over music. After Smith tried a few Warner Bros. sessions with label president Jim Ed Norman and felt none of the outside material fit her voice, she called Stuart to ask if he would write with her.
For what both later called their first date, Stuart came over to work on an unfinished idea Smith had been carrying around for years. Joined by veteran Nashville songwriter Harlan Howard, they finished the opening track, “How Long,” and followed it by writing “Hearts Like Ours”.
One song quickly led to another around the table until the pair had co-written nine of the ten tracks for the project, including “Lonesome,” “Love’s Not Everything,” “Just Let Me Know,” and “When It Comes to You”. They even experimented with an unconventional five-minute closing ballad titled “A Tale from Tahrarrie,” which Smith built around an imagined seventeenth-century Irish melody.
When the couple attended a Warner Bros. gathering alongside Travis and Theresa Tritt, Jim Ed Norman asked Smith what she had been doing since their earlier aborted studio dates. Stuart stepped in to say they had been writing songs together, and when Norman asked if Stuart wanted to be involved in the record, the mandolin player replied that he would do anything from carrying her water on up.
Inside the studio, Stuart co-produced the sessions alongside engineer Justin Niebank, surrounding Smith’s voice with top acoustic and electric players including steel guitarist Gary Hogue, fiddler Stuart Duncan, and guitarists Mark Casstevens, Biff Watson, and Stuart Smith. Rather than chasing nineties radio trends or cutting the duet project the label initially suggested, Stuart played guitar and mandolin and sang only a single line of harmony so the entire spotlight stayed on Smith.
While the album took shape behind studio doors, Smith remained cautious about their growing romance. Reluctant to risk a fourth heartbreak or invite Music Row gossip over their seventeen-year age difference, she kept her guard up until Stuart quieted his fast-lane routine, shared her Christian faith, and courted her privately under the watch of her children and his family for nearly three years.
Whenever skeptics around Nashville brought up the age gap, Stuart’s mother, Hilda, cut the talk short by reminding people of the vow her son had made in the car leaving the Mississippi fairgrounds in 1970.
On July 8, 1997, more than a year before Warner Bros. released the finished self-titled album *Connie Smith* in October 1998, the fifty-five-year-old singer and thirty-eight-year-old producer bypassed Nashville’s social scene to wed on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota. There, among the Lakota Sioux community that had adopted Stuart, they held a multi-day ceremony blending Lakota traditions with their Christian faith.
When *Connie Smith* finally arrived in stores as the thirty-fourth solo studio album of her career, mainstream country stations refused to add the fifty-seven-year-old singer to their playlists, prompting Warner Bros. to release the collection without sending a single to radio. Critics, however, praised the ten-song set, and the collaboration established a creative partnership that later yielded *Long Line of Heartaches* in 2011, *The Cry of the Heart* in 2021, and *Love, Prison, Wisdom and Heartaches* in 2024.
Nearly three decades after those 1994 writing sessions, the framed 1970 snapshot from the Philadelphia fairground still sits inside their home overlooking the Cumberland River, where the boy in the yellow shirt grew up to produce the woman he promised his mother he would marry.