OldiesSong

Greatest Hits Oldies But Goodies Ever

In 1956, teenage brothers Don and Harold Reid saved their spare change in Staunton, Virginia, to buy Elvis Presley records, never imagining he would one day walk into a Hollywood studio to sing a song Don wrote at home. By November 1974, The Statler Brothers — Don Reid, Harold Reid, Phil Balsley, and Lew DeWitt — released “Susan When She Tried” on their album Sons of the Motherland. Written solely by Don Reid, the song stepped away from the standard heartbreak ballads of 1970s country radio. Instead of dwelling on misery, it honored a woman who quietly wiped her tears, fixed her makeup, and held her head high after a painful breakup. The single climbed to No. 15 on the Billboard Hot Country Singles chart in early 1975. That message of quiet recovery soon reached Elvis Presley, who had long admired the quartet’s four-part gospel harmonies and was carrying his own private loneliness following his divorce from Priscilla Presley. On March 10 and 11, 1975, Presley stepped into RCA Studio C in Hollywood to record his own upbeat country-rock version of Don Reid’s song. Those March sessions proved to be the final professional recording studio dates of Presley’s life before he recorded exclusively at Graceland. Presley’s rendition appeared in April 1975 as the B-side to his single “T-R-O-U-B-L-E” and was featured on his album Today that May. When the advance record arrived in Virginia, the four bandmates gathered like kids to listen, falling silent the moment Presley’s voice filled the room with the melody Don had written at a wooden table back home. Even after winning Grammy and CMA awards, the Reid brothers kept a copy of Presley’s Today album in the place of honor in their Staunton memorabilia room.

Please scroll down for the video. It is at the end of the article!

When Elvis Presley walked into RCA Studio C on Sunset Boulevard in Hollywood on March 10, 1975, he was stepping into a commercial recording studio for the last time in his life, and tucked into his song stack was a tune written at a table in Staunton, Virginia, by Don Reid.

Long before The Statler Brothers had a bus or a record contract, teenage brothers Don and Harold Reid saved their spare change in Virginia to buy Presley’s 45s. Along with childhood friends Phil Balsley and Lew DeWitt, they grew up studying gospel quartets and singing four-part harmonies before spending more than eight years touring as part of Johnny Cash’s road show.

By 1974, the four Virginia friends were recording for Mercury Records in Nashville with producer Jerry Kennedy and engineer Tom Sparkman. For their album Sons of the Motherland, released that November, Don Reid wrote a solo composition titled “Susan When She Tried”.

Issued as a single in late 1974, the Statlers’ recording climbed to No. 15 on the Billboard Hot Country Singles chart in early 1975. Rather than leaning on the typical barroom self-pity of 1970s breakup numbers, Reid wrote a brisk reflection on a man looking back at past heartbreaks and realizing none of those women compared to the memory of one former partner.

While the single was still getting regular spins on country radio, producer Felton Jarvis was pulling together material for Presley’s upcoming studio dates in California. Presley had just spent late January and the first half of February 1975 recovering at Baptist Memorial Hospital in Memphis while his father, Vernon, recuperated from a heart attack in the room next door.

Still dealing with the long emotional fallout of his divorce from Priscilla Presley, Elvis gravitated toward contemporary country songs that mixed heartbreak with a strong rhythm. Having admired multi-part vocal groups and gospel quartets since his youth, he already knew The Statler Brothers’ work and picked Reid’s new hit for the Hollywood sessions.

Presley flew to Los Angeles on March 3 and arrived at RCA Studio C on the morning of March 10 with his young daughter, Lisa Marie, to begin three nights of work with Jarvis and engineer Rick Ruggieri. Inside the room was his touring band, including lead guitarist James Burton, rhythm guitarist John Wilkinson, drummer Ronnie Tutt, bassist Duke Bardwell, keyboardists Glen D. Hardin, David Briggs, and Tony Brown, and harmony partner Charlie Hodge.

During the second session on March 11, after finishing takes of “Green, Green Grass of Home” and Don McLean’s “And I Love You So,” Presley turned to “Susan When She Tried”. Working through six takes, he and Burton drove the arrangement with a punchy country-rock beat that moved even faster than the Statlers’ Nashville version.

Over those three days between March 10 and March 12, Presley completed ten masters, including “T-R-O-U-B-L-E,” “Fairytale,” and “Pieces of My Life”. Once he walked out of RCA Studio C, he never worked inside a professional recording studio again, cutting all of his remaining music in the Jungle Room at Graceland.

RCA included “Susan When She Tried” on Presley’s Today album on May 7, 1975, and also pressed it onto 45-rpm singles alongside “T-R-O-U-B-L-E.” When an advance copy of the record arrived at the Statler Brothers’ offices in Staunton, Don and Harold Reid, Balsley, and DeWitt crowded around a turntable to listen.

Nobody in the room spoke as the needle dropped and the man whose records they had saved coins to buy in 1956 began singing Don’s melody. Across a career that brought The Statler Brothers three Grammy Awards and nine Country Music Association Vocal Group of the Year trophies, the Reid brothers kept a copy of Presley’s Today album displayed in the place of honor inside their Virginia memorabilia room.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W6DmeR9a6ig

Related Post

When Tim McGraw and Faith Hill filmed the music video for “It’s Your Love” in the spring of 1997, they chose not to hide her pregnancy from the camera. Written by Stephony Smith, the ballad was the lead single from McGraw’s fourth studio album, Everywhere. It was also the couple’s first recorded duet since their quiet wedding in Rayville, Louisiana, the previous October, following months of Nashville gossip over how quickly their relationship had begun on the road. When director Sherman Halsey rolled the cameras, Hill was seven months pregnant with their first child. While 1990s music videos usually framed expecting singers from the shoulders up, Hill stepped under the studio lights in a simple black dress that made their growing family the center of the room. Throughout the shoot, the performance stayed close to real life. Between verses, McGraw rested his hand on his wife’s stomach and leaned his forehead against hers, looking at her the way a new husband looks at the mother of his child before the baby arrives. Released that April, “It’s Your Love” spent six consecutive weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard country chart and crossed over to No. 7 on the Billboard Hot 100. The record later swept the Academy of Country Music Awards for Single, Song, Video, and Vocal Event of the Year, and earned the Country Music Association trophy for Vocal Event of the Year. Their daughter Gracie was born that May, just as the song was climbing the radio charts. Nearly three decades later, the video still plays like a family home movie from the spring before their first child came into the world.

When Faith Hill stepped onto the Spontaneous Combustion Tour in the spring of 1996, she was wearing another man’s engagement ring and opening for Tim McGraw. At the time, Hill was engaged to Scott Hendricks, the Nashville producer behind her early records, while McGraw had recently ended a relationship of his own. Night after night on the road, McGraw stood at the side of the stage watching her set, and the distance between two tourmates quickly disappeared. Walking away from that engagement in the middle of a rising career came with a real cost. Nashville gossip was unforgiving toward a woman who left a respected producer, yet Hill chose to return the ring rather than step into a marriage when her heart already belonged somewhere else. On a rainy June 26, 1996, inside a dressing trailer at Country Jam in Grand Junction, Colorado, McGraw took her hands and asked her to marry him right before his show. He had to walk onstage before she gave him a serious answer. When he returned to the trailer, he found lipstick kisses and a note across his foldout dressing mirror, promising she would be his wife. That October 6, they invited family and friends to his aunt’s yard in Rayville, Louisiana, for what everyone thought was a charity softball game. Instead, expecting their first daughter, Gracie, Hill stepped off the bus in a simple white dress with pearls and stood barefoot in the grass to marry him under a tree. Thirty years and three daughters later, McGraw and Hill still keep that dressing room mirror from Colorado, a quiet piece of the summer she traded certainty for a life that lasted.

Harold Reid spent over 200 days a year making audiences laugh as the bass singer of The Statler Brothers, while his wife Brenda stayed back in Staunton, Virginia, raising their five children on her own. Long before the quartet toured with Johnny Cash or won Grammy and CMA awards, Harold married his high school sweetheart, Brenda Ann Fitzgerald, in 1959 when both were in their twenties. Even as the group’s fame grew from the 1970s through the 1990s, the couple refused to relocate to Nashville. They stayed in the Shenandoah Valley so their four daughters and one son, Kim, Karmen, Kodi, Kasey, and Wil, could attend local public schools and grow up in their hometown church. Whenever the tour bus pulled out of Staunton, Brenda managed the house and farm alone. She sat up through fevers, fixed broken household items, and drove the kids to school meetings or the emergency room without complaining over the phone so Harold could focus on the stage. At the large wooden dinner table, she included Harold in the nightly prayer, told the children which state their father was singing in that evening, and had them make small handmade gifts for his return. After cleaning the kitchen for six and putting the youngest to bed on winter nights, she often sat alone in the living room by the landline phone, waiting for his midnight call from a distant hotel or truck stop. Standing nearly six-foot-five and known as the group’s comedian, Harold shed his stage persona the moment he stepped off the bus to the smell of Brenda’s baking. He often told friends that his greatest pride was never a music trophy, but the wife who kept their home light burning for over sixty years. After Harold retired in 2002 and later battled kidney failure, Brenda and all five children, along with a family that grew to include thirteen grandchildren, stayed by his side until he passed away at age 80 on April 24, 2020.

At twenty-two, Eilleen Twain put her recording dreams on hold to raise her three younger siblings after a highway crash in northern Ontario took both of their parents. On November 1, 1987, her mother Sharon and stepfather Jerry died in a collision with a logging truck. Instead of pursuing music in Toronto, Eilleen became the legal guardian to nineteen-year-old Mark, eighteen-year-old Carrie-Ann, and fourteen-year-old Darryl. In 1988, manager Mary Bailey helped her land a steady singing job at Deerhurst Resort in Huntsville, Ontario. Eilleen moved the teenagers into a small nearby house, paid off their parents’ debts, and kept the family from being separated. Up to that point, she had sung country and rock in smoky bars wearing jeans, boots, and flannel shirts, or worked planting trees in the northern woods near Timmins. At Deerhurst, she had to headline Vegas-style revues like Viva Vegas and For the Love of Broadway, singing George Gershwin and Andrew Lloyd Webber twice a night, six days a week. Unused to high heels and choreography, she often stayed behind in the empty rehearsal room after the trained dancers went home, practicing steps in front of the mirror until she stopped stumbling. Because custom gowns were too expensive, she bought cheap fabric and bags of sequins, sitting at the kitchen table past midnight with needle-pricked fingers to sew her own stage dresses while her siblings slept. Once the curtain fell in front of the resort’s wealthy guests, she wiped off her makeup, put on a worn coat, and went home to pay winter heating bills, check homework, and make breakfast. In the summer of 1990, her youngest brother Darryl graduated from high school, and her siblings were old enough to stand on their own. Using the last of her Deerhurst savings, she recorded a country demo tape that soon reached producers in Nashville, where she took the name Shania Twain and carried every skill from that resort stage into her diamond-selling career.

Shania Twain waited fifteen years between albums, and when she finally returned at age 52, she did it with a changed voice and no creative safety net. On September 29, 2017, Mercury Nashville released Now, her first studio album since Up! in November 2002. By October, it had debuted at No. 1 on both the Billboard 200 and the Top Country Albums chart, moving 137,000 units, including 134,000 pure album sales. At fourteen years and ten months, it gave Twain the longest gap between No. 1 Billboard 200 albums for a female country artist. The silence behind those fifteen years had been brutal. A 2003 tick bite left her with Lyme disease and dysphonia, damaging the nerves in her vocal cords until she could no longer sing. Then in 2008, her fourteen-year marriage to producer Robert John “Mutt” Lange ended after his affair with her close friend and assistant, Marie-Anne Thiébaud. Twain found steady ground again in 2011 when she married Frédéric Thiébaud, the former husband of the friend who had betrayed her. Still, making music required starting over alone. Every song from her 1990s diamond era had been written and produced with Lange. For Now, Twain sat alone with an acoustic guitar in the Bahamas and Switzerland, writing all sixteen tracks on the deluxe edition by herself. Despite having sold over 100 million records, she was nervous to send rough vocal demos to new producers Matthew Koma, Ron Aniello, Jake Gosling, and Jacquire King. To rebuild her voice, she underwent open-throat thyroplasty surgery, remaining awake on the operating table to sing while doctors adjusted Gore-Tex implants against her vocal cords. Her voice returned lower and huskier than the clear tone of Come On Over. When the call came in October 2017 that Now was No. 1 in America, Twain broke down in tears, knowing she had written and sung her way back on her own.

In early 1974, the Bee Gees were singing over the clatter of knives and forks at the Batley Variety Club in northern England when a suggestion from Eric Clapton pointed them toward Miami. After their album “Mr. Natural” stalled, radio stations had largely moved on from Barry, Robin, and Maurice Gibb, leaving the twenty-seven-year-old Barry wondering if their run was finished. Back in London, Clapton, who shared manager Robert Stigwood with the brothers, had just overcome heroin addiction and recorded his comeback album at 461 Ocean Boulevard in Florida. He told Barry the trio needed to leave England, rent that same oceanfront house in Golden Beach, and work at Miami’s Criteria Studios. With RSO Records treating the next project as a last chance, Stigwood paired them with Atlantic Records producer Arif Mardin, known for his records with Aretha Franklin and Dusty Springfield. In the living room at 461 Ocean Boulevard, the brothers sat together with acoustic guitars again, while Mardin patiently steered them away from slow British ballads toward driven American R&B. Each day, driving across Biscayne Bay on the Julia Tuttle Causeway to reach Criteria Studios, Barry listened to the car tires thumping rhythmically over the bridge’s concrete expansion joints. That daily sound became the chugging pulse of “Jive Talkin’,” giving the group their first American number-one single in four years. During sessions for “Nights on Broadway,” Mardin asked if anyone could sing a high, forceful ad-lib over the fade-out. Barry stepped to the microphone and pushed his voice into a piercing falsetto none of them knew he had, leaving Mardin, Robin, and Maurice stunned in the control room. That new sound carried their 1975 album “Main Course” to platinum status and set up the worldwide run of “Saturday Night Fever” two years later, all starting from a rented house in Miami and the rhythm of tires on a Florida bridge.

In 1974, when the Bee Gees were playing small clubs across northern England and Maurice Gibb was drinking heavily after a high-profile divorce, he met a woman outside the music business who stayed with him for the next twenty-eight years. A year earlier, his four-year marriage to Scottish pop star Lulu had ended under the weight of packed schedules and his worsening alcoholism. At the same time, the Bee Gees’ records were stalling on the charts. At twenty-five, Maurice met Yvonne Spenceley, a quiet woman who wanted nothing from the spotlight. They married on October 17, 1975, just as Maurice and his brothers Barry and Robin moved to Miami to record “Main Course” and launch the R&B and disco run around “Saturday Night Fever.” Away from the cameras, Yvonne built a steady home for him and their two children, Adam, born in 1976, and Samantha, born in 1980. Behind the harmony and bass lines that held his strong-willed brothers together, Maurice fought severe alcoholism from the late 1970s into the early 1990s. At his lowest point, paranoia led him to carry a handgun around the house, forcing Yvonne to temporarily take the children away for their safety, though she never filed for divorce. In the early 1990s, her firm boundary pushed him to enter Alcoholics Anonymous, knowing she and the children would be waiting at home if he got well. After getting sober by 1992, Maurice stayed clean for the last decade of his life and returned to his role as the peacemaker between Barry and Robin. Until his death in Miami on January 12, 2003, at age fifty-three, he told interviewers that Yvonne’s patience since 1974 had kept him from dying young like his brother Andy and allowed him to watch his children grow up.

On September 30, 1987, some of the biggest names in music walked onto a Los Angeles stage and spent the night working as Roy Orbison’s backing band. For much of the 1970s, American radio had largely moved past the man behind those towering early-1960s ballads. After losing his wife Claudette in a 1966 motorcycle crash and his two oldest sons in a 1968 house fire, Orbison spent years playing small clubs in Britain and Europe while disco and hard rock dominated back home. The tide turned on January 21, 1987, at New York’s Waldorf-Astoria, when Bruce Springsteen inducted him into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Springsteen recalled lying in a New Jersey bedroom at twenty listening to Orbison’s records and told the room he had aimed for that voice when making his 1975 album “Born to Run.” Eight months later, producer T Bone Burnett gathered a lineup at the Ambassador Hotel’s Coconut Grove to film “Roy Orbison and Friends: A Black and White Night” on 35mm black-and-white film. Springsteen, Elvis Costello, Tom Waits, Bonnie Raitt, Jackson Browne, k.d. lang, and J.D. Souther asked for no solo turns. For an hour across seventeen songs, they played rhythm and sang harmony behind the fifty-one-year-old singer in his dark glasses. Standing at Orbison’s right hand, fresh off his massive “Born in the U.S.A.” run, Springsteen grinned toward his hero, traded guitar lines at the edge of the stage, and held his volume back whenever they shared a microphone so Orbison’s three-octave voice could lead. In an audience of about five hundred guests, Bob Dylan, George Harrison, Kris Kristofferson, Billy Idol, and Patrick Swayze rose to applaud after song after song. After the special aired on HBO in early 1988, Orbison joined the Traveling Wilburys and recorded “Mystery Girl.” When he died of a heart attack on December 6, 1988, at age fifty-two, just fourteen months after that Coconut Grove taping, he had already heard a generation of masters tell him to his face that his voice had never been forgotten.

In early 1958, Roy Orbison could not afford a proper gift for his young wife, so he put her name on a song that eventually bought him his musical freedom. Months after marrying sixteen-year-old Claudette Frady in November 1957, the twenty-one-year-old singer was broke in Memphis. His early hit “Ooby Dooby” had faded, and his subsequent Sun Records singles failed while producer Sam Phillips pushed him toward uptempo rockabilly instead of the ballads he wanted to sing. Unable to pay rent, Roy moved his bride into a small spare bedroom in his in-laws’ apartment. Some days they counted loose change from coat pockets just to buy bread and milk, and Roy nearly quit music for oil-field labor in West Texas. Watching Claudette endure the debt without complaint, he wrote an upbeat love song titled “Claudette” and played it for her on the edge of their bed. In March 1958, the couple drove to Terre Haute, Indiana, to see the Everly Brothers perform. Backstage in a cramped dressing room, learning Don and Phil Everly needed material for an upcoming Nashville session, Roy borrowed a guitar and sang the tribute he had written for his wife. The brothers asked to record it on the spot. Giving up the song meant letting go of his most personal piece of writing, yet Roy handed it over, knowing their rising fame could rescue his family. Publisher Wesley Rose placed “Claudette” on the B-side of “All I Have to Do Is Dream” in April 1958. As the single sold millions and hit number one, the B-side climbed into the Billboard Top 30 on its own. The royalty checks paid off the young couple’s debts, bought Roy out of his Sun Records contract, and led Wesley Rose to bring him to Monument Records, where ballads like “Only the Lonely” and “Crying” soon followed. When Claudette died in a motorcycle accident in June 1966 at age twenty-four, the three-minute gift from that borrowed Memphis bedroom remained the song that had started his true voice and carried her name for the rest of his life.