
On September 22, 1999, inside the Grand Ole Opry House in Nashville, 40-year-old Alan Jackson walked onto the live CBS broadcast of the 33rd Annual CMA Awards, stopped his scheduled single midway through, and used his network airtime to sing George Jones’s “Choices.”
Hours earlier, during the afternoon camera rehearsals, Jackson and his touring band, The Strayhorns, had played his current chart single, a cover of Jim Ed Brown’s “Pop a Top,” from start to finish so television directors and CMA executives would suspect nothing. Once the band returned to the dressing room behind the Opry stage, Jackson closed the door and worked out a secret transition with steel guitarist Robbie Flint and fiddle player Mark McClurg.
The decision to alter the live broadcast grew out of a dispute between Country Music Association producers and the 68-year-old Jones. Six months earlier, on March 6, 1999, Jones had nearly died after crashing his Lexus SUV into a bridge abutment on Old Hickory Boulevard near his home in Franklin, Tennessee. Suffering a collapsed lung and a ruptured liver, Jones spent nearly two weeks in Vanderbilt University Medical Center before returning home to recover.
That summer, Jones released the album *Cold Hard Truth*, built around the Billy Yates and Mike Curtis ballad “Choices,” supplied to him by producer Keith Stegall, who also produced all of Jackson’s records. Reflecting directly on decades of alcoholism and hard living, the recording earned Jones a 1999 CMA nomination for Male Vocalist of the Year and Single of the Year consideration.
Despite the critical reception, CMA and CBS executives declined to give the Hall of Fame singer a full three-minute performance slot, asking him instead to trim “Choices” down to roughly ninety seconds or weave it into a shortened medley to preserve airtime for younger commercial crossover acts. Insulted by the time restriction after more than four decades of hits, Jones refused the offer and stayed home in Franklin with his wife, Nancy.
For Jackson, the slight involved the artist who had anchored his music since he moved to Tennessee from Newnan, Georgia, in 1985. When Jackson released his 1991 signature hit “Don’t Rock the Jukebox,” he built the chorus around a tribute to Jones’s voice, and Jones traveled to set to make a surprise cameo at the counter in the music video.
Three years later, in 1994, the two teamed up to record “A Good Year for the Roses” for Jones’s duets project *The Bradley Barn Sessions*, earning a CMA nomination together in 1995. Over the 1990s, Jones became both a mentor and a close friend, visiting Jackson’s home and sharing bills on the road.
It was also not the first time Jackson had used a live network broadcast to protest industry politics alongside his band. Five years earlier, at the 1994 ACM Awards, he had sent drummer Bruce Rutherford onstage with no drumsticks after producers required bands to play to pre-recorded backing tracks.
When host Vince Gill introduced Jackson at the 1999 CMA Awards, The Strayhorns kicked off the upbeat shuffle of “Pop a Top” right on cue. After singing the first verse and the opening chorus, Jackson stepped back, gave a hand signal to the band, and brought the tempo to a halt.
As the CBS control room and teleprompter operators scrambled to figure out what had gone wrong, Flint played the crying pedal steel intro to “Choices.” Standing beneath the stage lights in his white cowboy hat, black shirt, and blue jeans, Jackson sang the entire second half of Jones’s song without changing a word.
In Franklin, watching the television broadcast from his living room couch, Jones held Nancy’s hand and wept as Jackson finished the final verse. Inside the Grand Ole Opry House, fellow artists and industry executives rose to their feet in a sustained standing ovation. Jackson offered no speech into the microphone, tipped the brim of his white Stetson, and walked into the wings.
The next morning, Jones sent a large floral arrangement and a personal note of gratitude to Jackson’s Nashville office. Five months later, on February 23, 2000, “Choices” won Jones the Grammy Award for Best Male Country Vocal Performance, his first solo Grammy win in nineteen years.
Fourteen years after that September night, on May 2, 2013, following Jones’s death at age 81, Jackson walked back onto the exact same Grand Ole Opry House stage in his white cowboy hat, stood beside his friend’s open casket, and closed the public funeral service by singing “He Stopped Loving Her Today” before tipping his hat and walking off once more.