
After Marty Stuart and Cindy Cash ended their five-year marriage in 1988, he kept his house right next door to Johnny Cash on Caudill Drive and still walked across the lawn for morning coffee like a son.
In Hendersonville, Tennessee, Johnny Cash and June Carter Cash separated the end of a young marriage from the personal bond they had built with Stuart since he joined Cash’s road band at age 21 in 1980. Their stone-and-timber home at 200 Caudill Drive sat along the banks of Old Hickory Lake, across the street from where Cash’s mother, Carrie, had lived. Living beside that lakefront compound meant Stuart remained part of the daily rhythm of the household, dropping in unannounced to drink coffee, eat cheeseburgers, work in the yard, or talk music.
Between their properties lay a quiet stretch of lakeside land with its own history. The lot at 185 Caudill Drive had once belonged to Cash’s friend and neighbor Roy Orbison before a 1968 house fire claimed the lives of two of Orbison’s young sons. Cash had acquired the land, promised Orbison no house would ever be built over the ashes, and planted a fruit orchard there instead. For years along Old Hickory Lake, Stuart walked past those fruit trees on his way to visit his former father-in-law.
When Stuart married Grand Ole Opry singer Connie Smith in 1997, Johnny and June welcomed her into the Caudill Drive circle without hesitation. Cash treated Stuart’s career milestones with pride, and the two neighbors continued trading guest appearances on each other’s records, including their 1992 duet “This One’s Gonna Hurt You (For a Long, Long Time)”.
That trust carried into the studio during the mid-1990s when producer Rick Rubin began recording Cash’s American Recordings series. For the 1996 album *Unchained*, which paired Cash with Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers and earned a Grammy for Best Country Album, Stuart stepped in to play guitar and help bridge Cash’s traditional instincts with the new sessions.
As autonomic neuropathy and diabetes later dimmed Cash’s eyesight and weakened his voice, the stone house on Old Hickory Lake became what Stuart described as both a sanctuary and a fortress. On quiet afternoons when Cash did not feel up to talking, the two men sat together on the porch overlooking the water and traded a few acoustic guitar notes in silence. Cash also allowed Stuart to bring his camera inside the house, trusting his neighbor to take candid black-and-white portraits of him during his frail final years.
In May 2003, June Carter Cash died at age 73, leaving her husband grieving and largely confined to a wheelchair. Over the next four months, Stuart and Connie stayed close to the house at 200 Caudill Drive to keep him company.
Four days before Cash died on September 12, 2003, Stuart walked next door with a cup of coffee to play him a new album of traditional gospel songs he had recorded with his band, the Fabulous Superlatives. Sitting together one last time, Cash held Stuart’s hand and urged him to ignore slick commercial trends in Nashville and stay true to traditional country and gospel music.
At the funeral in Hendersonville, Stuart stood alongside Cindy, Rosanne, and John Carter Cash, who later entrusted him with safeguarding Cash’s first black stage suit, touring boots, guitars, and handwritten manuscripts.
Even after Johnny and June were gone, Stuart and Connie Smith kept watch over the neighborhood they had shared. They purchased the adjacent orchard lot on Caudill Drive from John Carter Cash, cleared away the rotting railroad ties, tended the aging fruit trees, and built a gate and cross so the promise Cash made to Roy Orbison on Old Hickory Lake would never be broken.