
When Connie Smith released her self-titled comeback album on October 6, 1998, her name appeared in the songwriting credits on nine of the record’s ten tracks, more than she had written on any project across her previous thirty-four years in country music.
Before those late-1990s sessions with Marty Stuart, the singer behind 1964’s eight-week No. 1 debut “Once a Day” had spent twenty years away from commercial recording studios. Following her 1978 Monument Records release *New Horizons*, Smith stepped off the touring highway to stay home in Tennessee and raise her five children—Darren, Kerry, Giselle, Julie, and Jeanne—limiting her public appearances mostly to weekend broadcasts at the Grand Ole Opry.
She later explained that if she had pursued her music career to the extent the industry demanded, her family would have suffered, and she wanted to make sure her children knew she was their mother first.
By the mid-1990s, with all five children grown, Smith attended a Warner Bros. Records party alongside Stuart and their friends Travis and Theresa Tritt. The first executive she ran into was label president Jim Ed Norman, who told her he had been looking for her and asked if she was still interested in making records.
Signing with Warner Bros. opened a new question about what kind of material a fifty-seven-year-old traditional singer should cut after two decades away. During her 1960s and 1970s hit run at RCA and Columbia, Smith had rarely written her own singles, relying instead on tunes crafted by her mentor Bill Anderson and songwriter Dallas Frazier, who supplied signature cuts like “Ain’t Had No Lovin’,” “Where Is My Castle,” and “Just for What I Am”.
By the time Smith prepared to return to the studio, Frazier had largely stepped away from commercial songwriting to focus on the ministry. Rather than combing through outside publishing catalogs, Stuart—then at the height of his own run of gold and platinum albums—encouraged Smith to trust her own notebook and write the record with him.
Whenever Smith hesitated over a line or moved to cross out an idea at the table, Stuart sat across from her with an acoustic guitar and kept her from throwing the pages away. Those writing sessions quickly grew into a quiet courtship, leading to their marriage on July 8, 1997, on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota before the album was finished.
Together, Smith and Stuart wrote six of the album’s songs entirely on their own: “Lonesome,” “Hearts Like Ours,” “Love’s Not Everything,” “Just Let Me Know,” “When It Comes to You,” and the five-minute closing ballad “A Tale From Tahrarrie”.
For the album’s opening track, “How Long,” Stuart brought Smith into a room with Hall of Fame songwriter Harlan Howard, who had written some of her earliest 1960s studio cuts. To ease the nerves of the session, Smith added a playful yodel at the very end of the vocal take just to be funny, and Stuart and co-producer Justin Niebank kept it on the final master.
Smith also branched out to write with younger Nashville tunesmiths who had grown up admiring her records. She teamed with Allen Shamblin and Stuart to write the spiritually grounded “Your Light,” and co-wrote the four-minute ballad “Looking for a Reason” with singer-songwriter Curtis Wright, leaving Tom Shapiro and Chris Waters’s “You Can’t Take Back a Teardrop” as the lone outside song on the tracklist.
On the closing composition, “A Tale From Tahrarrie,” Smith and Stuart set out to write a story song that sounded like it belonged in the 1700s, with Smith inventing the Irish-sounding name in the title to match the melody. When people around town remarked that the piece sounded different from the rest of the project, Smith replied that it was meant to show another side of her artistry.
Inside Nashville’s Sound Emporium and Hound’s Ear Studio, Stuart and Niebank built the instrumentation around her voice, pairing Stuart’s mandolin and guitar work with fiddle player Stuart Duncan, lead guitarist Stuart Smith, pianist Gary Smith, and harmony vocalists Sharon White and Cheryl White.
When Warner Bros. issued *Connie Smith* on October 6, 1998, critics noted that two decades off the road had left her contralto richer and more controlled than ever.
That late-1990s songwriting breakthrough reshaped the rest of her career. After Smith was inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame in 2012, she and Stuart continued writing together across her 2011 album *Long Line of Heartaches* and 2021’s *The Cry of the Heart*, proving that the mother who paused her stardom for twenty years still had plenty of her own stories left to put on paper.