
In 1997, Capitol Records prepared a recording contract for fourteen-year-old Carrie Underwood, then scrapped the offer after a sudden change in company leadership. For the next seven years, the future country star put away any expectation of a music career and built a quiet, practical life in eastern Oklahoma.
Raised on a family farm in rural Checotah, Underwood grew up as the youngest daughter of Stephen Underwood, who worked at a paper mill, and Carole Underwood, an elementary school teacher. Her earliest audiences were the congregation at First Free Will Baptist Church and neighbors gathered for Checotah’s annual Old Settler’s Day and local Lions Club events.
When an admirer in town arranged for her to travel to Nashville at age fourteen, her parents covered the trip on their steady working wages. Her audition impressed the staff at Capitol Records enough that a contract was drawn up, only for a corporate shakeup inside the label to cancel the deal before anything was signed.
Rather than relocating to Tennessee or chasing another label executive, Underwood went straight back to Checotah High School. She still stepped onto regional stages occasionally, including singing in braces at the 1998 Miss Westark Pageant, while filling her routine with Honor Society meetings, cheerleading, basketball, and softball.
When she graduated as salutatorian of her high school class in 2001, she made a conscious decision to leave the idea of a recording career behind. She later explained that she felt she had reached a point where she needed to be practical and prepare for a future in the real world.
That fall, she enrolled about forty miles away at Northeastern State University in Tahlequah to study mass communication with an emphasis in journalism. Her goal was a steady job in television news once she earned her diploma.
Those college years between 2001 and 2004 were packed with ordinary student routines and part-time paychecks. Underwood joined the Alpha Iota chapter of the Sigma Sigma Sigma sorority and took on a string of local jobs, waiting tables at a pizzeria, working at a zoo, and assisting at a veterinary clinic.
Music remained part of her schedule in Tahlequah, though only as a campus and summer activity rather than a Nashville pursuit. She took a country music theater class alongside fellow student Zach Swon, who later found success with the Swon Brothers, and spent two summers performing in the university’s Downtown Country show in Tahlequah. She also entered campus pageants, finishing as runner-up for Miss NSU in 2004.
By the summer of 2004, Underwood was twenty-one and just three credits shy of completing her bachelor’s degree. Hearing about open auditions for the fourth season of American Idol, she traveled to St. Louis, Missouri, and sang Bonnie Raitt’s “I Can’t Make You Love Me” for the judges.
Passing the preliminary rounds earned her a trip to Hollywood and put her final semester on hold. Over the following months, the journalism student who had spent recent summers singing in Tahlequah never trailed in the weekly viewer voting, culminating in her victory on May 25, 2005, at age twenty-two.
Her debut album, Some Hearts, arrived later that year through 19 Recordings and Arista Nashville, launching a multi-platinum career. Even with a major tour underway and national awards arriving, Underwood returned to Tahlequah on May 6, 2006, to walk in Northeastern State University’s graduation ceremony.
The university granted her final three internship credits for the extensive television experience she had gained on national broadcasts, allowing her to graduate magna cum laude. True to the habits she formed during her college years, she declined media interviews that afternoon so she would not pull attention away from her classmates.
Years later, in March 2017, her career came full circle when she signed with Capitol Records Nashville, the same company that had prepared and canceled her teen contract twenty years earlier. Looking back on that 1997 disappointment, Underwood called the lost deal a blessing, recognizing that eight normal years of school, shift work, and growing up in Oklahoma prepared her to handle the stage when her name was finally called.