
On May 3, 1952, inside Castle Studio at Nashville’s Tulane Hotel, 32-year-old Kitty Wells stepped up to the microphone for a standard $125 union session fee and recorded an answer to a Hank Thompson B-side that reshaped country music.
That musical exchange had begun five months earlier, on December 11, 1951, when Hank Thompson and his Brazos Valley Boys entered a Capitol Records studio in Hollywood with producer Ken Nelson. Born in Waco, Texas, in 1925 and already a national name with his twin-fiddle and steel-guitar Western swing sound, Thompson cut a tune written by William Warren and Arlie Carter called “The Wild Side of Life.” Set to the traditional melody known from Roy Acuff’s “The Great Speckled Bird” and the Carter Family’s “I’m Thinking Tonight of My Blue Eyes,” the song told the story of a man blaming a woman for leaving home to chase honky-tonk lights.
Capitol issued the recording in March 1952 on the flip side of “The Waiting Time.” Radio disc jockeys and tavern jukebox patrons immediately turned the record over, sending “The Wild Side of Life” to number one on the Billboard country chart for fifteen straight weeks.
Down in Crowley, Louisiana, songwriter J.D. “Jay” Miller heard Thompson’s runaway hit and wrote a direct female rebuttal using the exact same melody. Titled “It Wasn’t God Who Made Honky Tonk Angels,” Miller’s lyric answered that married men pretending to be single were the real reason many women lost their way.
Decca Records producer Paul Cohen brought the song to Muriel Deason, the Nashville native who performed under the stage name Kitty Wells alongside her husband, Johnnie Wright, and his duo partner, Jack Anglin. Having dropped earlier by RCA Victor after being told female country singers could not sell records, Wells was preparing to leave the road to stay home with her three children, Ruby, Bobby, and Carol Sue. She agreed to attend the May 3, 1952 session at the Tulane Hotel mainly because her family could use the guaranteed $125 union scale.
Inside Castle Studio that day, Cohen surrounded her restrained vocals with the musicians from Johnnie & Jack’s Tennessee Mountain Boys: her husband Johnnie Wright on bass, Jack Anglin on rhythm guitar, Paul Warren on fiddle, and Shot Jackson playing the distinctive crying steel guitar intro that echoed Thompson’s hit. Released by Decca on June 23, 1952, backed with “I Don’t Want Your Money, I Want Your Time,” the single drew immediate censorship.
Executives at the NBC radio network banned the record as suggestive, and Grand Ole Opry management barred Wells from singing it live on the Ryman Auditorium stage or on the network’s *Prince Albert* broadcast. Record buyers ignored the restrictions, purchasing more than 800,000 copies and forcing both the network and the Opry to lift the ban.
That summer, as Thompson’s fifteen-week run at the top ended, “It Wasn’t God Who Made Honky Tonk Angels” replaced his record at number one on the Billboard country chart and held the spot for six weeks. Wells became the first solo female artist to top the chart, earning the lifelong title Queen of Country Music and opening the commercial door for Patsy Cline, Loretta Lynn, Tammy Wynette, and Dolly Parton.
Rather than treating the answer song as a rivalry, Thompson and Wells built a decades-long friendship, sharing package tour bills and trading verses on their paired hits for audiences across North America. Wells was inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame in 1976, and Thompson joined her there in 1989 after selling more than 60 million records across his career. Both original 1952 singles were later inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame—Wells’s Decca disc in 1998 and Thompson’s Capitol platter in 1999—and in 2007 the Library of Congress added Wells’s recording to the National Recording Registry.
Even at age 82, Thompson continued touring with his Brazos Valley Boys until doctors diagnosed him with terminal lung cancer in the fall of 2007. Determined to say goodbye on a Texas stage, he put on his white cowboy hat for a final concert in his hometown of Waco in October 2007, singing “The Wild Side of Life” one last time before dying at his home in Keller, Texas, on November 6, 2007. Wells lived nearly five years longer in Madison, Tennessee, until her passing at age 92 on July 16, 2012, sixty summers after her $125 session at Castle Studio answered Thompson’s jukebox hit across every radio in America.