
When Mike Fisher published his retirement letter in *The Tennessean* on August 3, 2017, Carrie Underwood celebrated the end of his seventeen-year NHL run while looking ahead to a quieter life on their 400-acre farm in Franklin, Tennessee.
At 37, the Nashville Predators captain was stepping away with 1,088 career games split between the Ottawa Senators and Nashville. His decision arrived less than two months after he guided the Predators to the first Stanley Cup Final in franchise history, a six-game battle against the Pittsburgh Penguins that ended on June 11, 2017, and turned downtown Broadway into a sea of gold jerseys.
In his open letter to the city, Fisher called walking away the hardest decision he had ever made. He wrote that he had spent the summer praying for peace about his next step, gradually realizing it was time to return the favor to his wife and their two-year-old son, Isaiah Michael, who had supported his career without question.
That morning, Underwood shared a photograph of her husband on the ice. She thanked him for the integrity he brought to his teammates and his quiet visits to local children’s hospitals, adding that she and Isaiah were excited to finally have him home and sit beside him in the stands at Bridgestone Arena.
For Underwood, the announcement closed a long chapter of holding her breath from a stadium suite. Introduced backstage at one of her concerts in late 2008 by her bassist, Mark Childers, the couple spent their early relationship navigating cross-border flights before marrying at Lake Oconee, Georgia, on July 10, 2010.
Seven months after the wedding, in February 2011, Ottawa traded Fisher to Nashville, allowing the newlyweds to live under one roof in Tennessee. Even then, playing center for nearly two decades left Fisher with cracked ribs, a broken foot, a dislocated shoulder, torn cartilage, and locker-room stitches between periods before he came home sore from the road.
Yet their transition into retirement took one unexpected detour five months later. In January 2018, watching Nashville make another contender’s push, Underwood kept asking Fisher every few days if he wanted to lace up his skates one last time to chase the trophy that had narrowly escaped him.
With her encouragement, Fisher came out of retirement on January 31, 2018, and signed a one-year deal on February 26 to finish the season. He played 16 regular-season games and 12 playoff contests before a lower-body injury in Game 6 against the Winnipeg Jets sidelined him, leading to his permanent retirement on May 12, 2018, after 18 NHL seasons.
Away from the rink, the years between 2017 and 2018 also tested the couple privately. As they tried to grow their family after welcoming Isaiah in February 2015, Underwood suffered three miscarriages in 2017 and early 2018, leaning heavily on Fisher and their shared faith at home.
That difficult stretch gave way to celebration on January 21, 2019, when they welcomed their second son, Jacob Bryan Fisher. Two months later, in March 2019, the Peterborough, Ontario native stood inside a federal courtroom waving a small American flag as he officially became a United States citizen.
When Underwood launched her *Cry Pretty Tour 360* in May 2019, the family’s old hockey schedule flipped completely. Fisher climbed onto the tour bus with four-year-old Isaiah and infant Jacob, trading arena locker rooms for backstage hallways so the family could stay together across North America.
Back on their acreage in Franklin, they settled into an everyday routine far removed from red carpets and stadium horns. While Fisher co-founded the outdoor lifestyle brand Catchin’ Deers and worked the land, Underwood tended her vegetable garden, orchard, chickens, horses, and donkeys between recording albums and later joining the judging panel on *American Idol*.
Tennessee formally recognized Fisher’s impact on the state in July 2023 by inducting him into the Tennessee Sports Hall of Fame. By the winter of 2024, the game that had shaped their marriage returned in a gentler form when five-year-old Jacob celebrated his birthday skating with a hockey stick across the frozen pond on their Franklin farm.
The bruising nights along the Bridgestone Arena boards are now part of team history, replaced by quiet mornings in the Tennessee hills where Fisher and Underwood are raising their two boys together.